Evan Longoria vs. Jacoby Ellsbury

[blujaysrock]

http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/headToH...4&type=hitting

i know they are two diff types of players but who would you rather have on your team?

EDIT: **** FORGOT A POLL!

[TheLogical]

Ellsbury, not because im a Red Sox fan, but because he performs great in the clutch, world series experience, faster than longoria, hits for better contact.

[Twitchy]

Ellsbury, not because im a Red Sox fan, but because he performs great in the clutch, world series experience, faster than longoria, hits for better contact.

O rly?

Longoria BA - 281
Ellsbury - 278

Ellsbury RISP OPS - 679
Longoria RISP OPS - 792 <--- Seems more clutch to me

I'll grant you that he's faster, but you're probably the only person who legitimately thinks Ellsbury is a better player than Longoria.

[PhillyUD26]

Longoria

[nyyfan4life]

Longoria and its not even close. He's younger and a much better offensive threat. He is going to be a menace in the AL east.

[brandonwarne52]

Evan Longoria FTW!

[Tragedy]

Longoria. He'll be the far better hitter in his career, I assume.

[FriarFanatic]

Longoria fo sho! he's a boss and will be a stud for years

[quiksilver2491]

Longoria by quite a margin. I don't think Ellsbury will ever be a franchise player you can build around, but more of a great complementary guy, Longoria is a guy you can center an offense around.

[Pujolsfan91]

Longoria

[C1Bman88]

Longoria, no doubt about it.

[sanfranfan1210]

Longoria

[Run Gardner Run]

Brett Gardner

[Brooke]

Longoria

[blujaysrock]

Brett Gardner

once he proves he can hit at major league level