Comparison that popped into my head today at work.
Who would you rather have?
Just checking now, they've both posted 118 OPS+ in their careers (with Ichiro's OBVIOUSLY being a longer career).
That said, Ichiro is 34, Fukudome is 31. Who do you want right now? For the next 5 years?
I think you have to grant 'career' to Ichiro, but if you feel otherwise, feel free to say so.