Post 256 was from you.
Type: Posts; User: jej
Post 256 was from you.
This has been addressed.
If they pitch at the same time and get hurt at the same time, it's a disadvantage.
If they pitch at separate times and get hurt at separate times it roughly the same...
Because he says so, of course.
Why? Because you say so? Why do FIP and SIERA just not matter?
Disagreeing is fine if you actually understand what you are disagreeing with, and can explain why the other side is wrong. You haven't done that.
FIP tells pretty much the same story, and has been said about 15 times now.
What does that even mean? Should it be guilty until proven innocent? Why does your faceless opinion make someone guilty or not guilty?
They aren't going to listen guys. Selective reading comprehension is rampant throughout this whole argument.
Wait... Before you said cumulative WAR was stupid. Now you are ignoring the fact that that isn't the argument, and you are the one using it because now it's furthering your argument.
Do you need...
I would too. But the fact is, they will provide similar production at the same cost. And no massive prospect haul.
Did you read anything Jeffy has said? He has addressed literally all of this.
And again, he never said it was as good. You arent grasping his point.
But what's wrong with cumulative WAR? It's a pretty good way of measuring value whether you accept it or not.
Remind me again what solid argument you have made here? All I've seen, per usual, is trolling.
How do you have McGriff but not Edgar or Raines?
I wouldn't say a steal. He is old, injury prone, should be a DH at least part time, and also costed a pick.
No, I didn't know what you meant then. If you meant something else, then why say that?
Except you clearly don't, because he never said McCarthy + Anderson > Hamels.
And Edgar, and Piazza, and Schilling.
How anyone can fall that short of the limit is beyond me. I would probably vote for at least 11 if there was no limit.
Bagwell, Bonds, Clemens, Randy Johnson, Pedro, Mussina, Piazza, Raines, Schilling, Walker
I really hate the 10 person limit. I am a strong proponent of Edgar, but I just saw a ballot posted on Twitter that didn't have him and I was totally okay with it.
Anyone (besides Ian) watch the Fargo TV show? ****ing amazing. Billy Bob and Martin Freeman.
You've earned it. But I can also only attack the person here because there is no real argument to begin with.
It's not because I made it. It's because no one else made any others besides "you are insane" and other fallacious bs.
Those that disagree haven't been able to present their side of it.
The only real argument against is one I brought up before, that you have to add Cole and the 5th starter and compare that to the...
Not if you understand his point.