near Pro Bowl < near MVP for Peyton and APQuote:
Originally Posted by homestarunner93
Printable View
near Pro Bowl < near MVP for Peyton and APQuote:
Originally Posted by homestarunner93
Peyton, came back from multiple major neck surgeries, missed ALL of last seaspn, and has led his team to a division win and possible 1st round bye.
Adrian Peterson has had an amazing season and deserves offensive playr of the year. But people forget AP played 12 games and had almost 1000 yeards and 12 rushing TD last year!!!
I love AP and the recovery from his injury is impressive as any Ive ever seen (besides Peyton's which is mor eimpressive imo), but AP shouldnt even qualify.In summary, I love AP and think he's the best RB in the league and could easily win OPOY, but he in no way deserves this award. He came back from and offseason surgery. he played 12 of 16 games, had basically 1000 yards, and 13 total TD. He does not deserve comeback player of the year. Manning does.
AP should win the mvp and the comeback player of the year
If he had destroyed his knee, or had four NECK surgeries, and then came back and was having a year in which he were in MVP discussion, I'd agree with you. But there's no way AP and Peyton don't get all the votes this yearQuote:
Originally Posted by homestarunner93
Did he have all 4 in one year? I thought he had two of those previouslyQuote:
Originally Posted by j11430
lol, what exactly would you call 3 ACL tears on one knee? Peyton's neck injury is blown way out of proportion. AP is very impressive for returning to a high form with his injury. I'm not saying Davis deserves it, but he should be in the discussion. The real question is, what should CPoY award be for? Is it coming back from unlikely odds or is it coming back and performing at an MVP level? Because TD has missed 38 games over the last three seasons and managed to come back and play very well. Even as a Panther fan I was ready to write TD off before the season.Quote:
Originally Posted by j11430
Id go Peyton with comeback player of the year then AP for MVP
Anyone who thinks Peterson should win comeback player of the year is kidding themselves he only missed 1 game.... yes he tore his acl n mcl but he didn't miss many games. It's Mannings award.
Sure, but their injuries weren't nearly as bad.Quote:
Originally Posted by Austeezy
That shows your ignorance, because he did destroy his knee...three times.Quote:
Originally Posted by j11430
peterosn without question
This. I was leaning to AP but he only missed 1 game. It's Manning's award. I got AP as the offensive player of the year though.Quote:
Originally Posted by 85BearsDefense
P. Manning without question. Who wins the tie-breaker?Quote:
Originally Posted by Pinstripe power
It's insane that the top 2 comeback players are the top 2 MVP candidates. AP and PM are the definition of put the team on your back
Ap........all day!!!!!