Brett Mayne and Scott Service > all
Printable View
Brett Mayne and Scott Service > all
PUDGE!!!! best defensive catcher mlb has EVER seen with best arm mlb will EVER see...that plus a bat that hit .300 consistently, no question
You dont even need to show all SABR stats to know it's Ivan
Ivan
Several pitchers have complained bitterly that IR only calls for 4 seam FB's when a runner is on 1st and 2nd is open, to pump up his CS%, not for the betterment of the team, or the pitchers ERA.Quote:
Originally Posted by kokes
A career made much longer by use of PED's?
So far YM is a better defender based on the games played/defense. Without PED's it's hard to see how he can keep up however.
It's not the question, but I would take Bench, Fisk and Carter over IR him every time. And consider Berra and Campanella as well.
IR is NOT the GOAT.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bagwell368
i too would take bench, fisk, carter and berra over pudge, but even with the complaints he still called a great game and helped his team every game...there's not many catchers out there that are going to consistently hit .300+ with that d
One of the main reasons I never was a Pudge fan.Quote:
Several pitchers have complained bitterly that IR only calls for 4 seam FB's when a runner is on 1st and 2nd is open, to pump up his CS%, not for the betterment of the team, or the pitchers ERA.