Smith or Sanchez for rest of there career.. who are you taking?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by legendary49ers

And Smith was sacked 44 times, so what? Compare the Jets WRs to the 49ers Wrs last year.

Holmes + Burress >>>>>>> Craptree + Brett Swain

---

the guy was option like 173 in the packers passing game when he was there................

I voted Smith. Sure, Sanchez has had more success but that's because he's had better teams until last season. In all honesty, I think the Jets have won inspite of Sanchez for the most part, not because of him. He seems like their weak link to me. I don't see them ever getting to the super bowl with him at QB. It seems like Smith just needed the right coach or system to get him on track. It was nice to see him do better after starting off his career with some tough times.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Beltrans Mole

Alex Smith had one solid year and has played in the NFL for what...seven seasons? I mean neither QB is great but Sanchez can make plays and has shown more potential in just three seasons than Smith has shown over seven. Yes, that's just my opinion but I'm sticking to it.

---

he's actually been solid his last 3 years......................

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 12to85

Give me Mark since he is the only one of the two that can complete passes to WRs

---

its not smiths fault he cant complete passes to wide recievers. the 49ers barely haven't had any his entire career................

Smith and its NOT close... Mark Sanchez is a really bad quarterback.

Rest of their career? From today on? Gotta give it to Smith. He's clearly mentally tougher than Sanchez, who at times seems like he could burst into tears at the drop of a hat. Obviously, the Tebow signing didn't help.

the daily gathering for the anti jet trolls has commenced

all the usual suspects

return to business as usual

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Five Angels

Rest of their career? From today on? Gotta give it to Smith. He's clearly mentally tougher than Sanchez, who at times seems like he could burst into tears at the drop of a hat. Obviously, the Tebow signing didn't help.

---

Yeah, because it's not like Alex Smith didn't throw a hissyfit when he found out the 49ers were pursuing Manning. The difference between Sanchez and Smith is that Smith actually has a coach who knows offense. Harbaugh would work wonders on Sanchez.

Smith

Smith > Sanchez

Its obvious

Going forward...I'm still going with Smith, but its not as obvious.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by utl768

the daily gathering for the anti jet trolls has commenced

all the usual suspects

return to business as usual

---

Yeah we should have all lied and said Sanchez to appease your fragile mind.

I still don't understand why Jets threads are made anymore on PSD. It's clear there is an overwhelming bias, don't even bother wasting your time.

i'm a bit surprised no one has asked for the easiest thing to solve this question yet. what are their madden ratings?

Smith>>Sanchez

and dont say cause im a homer 49er fan, I ****ing hate alex smith, but Sanchez is only a starting QB in this league because he was a product of the USC glory days

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nymfan87

Yeah, because it's not like Alex Smith didn't throw a hissyfit when he found out the 49ers were pursuing Manning. The difference between Sanchez and Smith is that Smith actually has a coach who knows offense. Harbaugh would work wonders on Sanchez.

---

you can polish a pile of **** all you want, at the end of the day, its still i pile of ****