Top 15 QBs in the NFL
1. Peyton Manning (great player, multiple MVPs, etc)
2. Tom Brady (up there with Peyton, 3 SBs)
3. Brett Favre (The legend is still playing good)
4. Eli Manning (Youngster on track for a spot in Canton)
5. Big Ben (Hall of Famer so long as injuries dont ruin his career)
6. Drew Brees (great fit with Payton on the Saints. Would not be as good elsewhere)
7. Phil Rivers (Very good, proven QB)
8. Aaron Rodgers (needs to show he can win games vs good teams)
9. Tony Romo (pretty good QB. Playoff victory would be huge for him)
10 Kurt Warner (Arizona is the perfect place for him)
11 Donovan Mcnabb (Good QB dogged by injuries and choking)
12 Matt Ryan
13 Matt Schuab (good player, but still has not ascended into top QB)
14 Jay Cutler (not gonna put too much stock in this season, guys still a solid player)
15 Carson Palmer (overrated. above average QB, not much more)
16 Joe Flacco (solid QB, will get better with time)
17 Vince Young (has the talent, mental questions abound though)
18 Chad Henne (This kid is gonna grow into a very good QB)
19 David Garrard (middle of the road starter whos getting old)
20 Kyle Orton (decent game manager)
is there a question with the thread or just stating?
And you said top 15 and listed 20
It's honestly a great list except for the ridiculous amount of homerism.
Cmon man. I love Eli, but 4 and on his way to canton? Cmon now.
Really why is Orton so low. Who is this "Peyton Manning". Orton's beard would grab him in its kung-fu grip.
5. Aaron Rodgers
12. Who cares?
13. Who cares?
14. Who cares?
15. Who cares?
1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Drew Brees
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Phillip Rivers
6. Aaron Rodgers
7. Brett Favre
8. Tony Romo
9. Carson Palmer
10. Donavan McNabb
11. Eli Manning
12. Kurt Warner
13. Joe Flacco
14. Matt Ryan
15. Matt Schuab
Just Missed: Vince Young.... Jay Cutler possibly.
why is schaub so low? led the NFL in passing yard (also the 6th most yards in NFL history) and was top 5 in nearly EVERY statistical passing category
He had a phenomenal year and if this thread had been titled top 15 QB's in 2009, I think he'd make a great case for top 5. Overall, I don't think this one season is enough to propel him into the ranks of the elite. If he repeats this type of success next year, then we have a debate on our hands.
Originally Posted by astrosmaniac
im not saying top 5 on this list, but 11, 12, and 15 so far? he was on pace for very good numbers last year. if not for low blow hits in the Minnesota game (lunging at the knee - same type of hit that made brady miss all of last year), then he would have had over 4400 yards, 22 TDs, 14 INTs, and a 66% completion rate. thats a pretty good 2 year sample.
Originally Posted by griff141
Originally Posted by Giants99
1- Mark Sanchez
2- Mark Sanchez
3- Mark Sanchez
4- Mark Sanchez
5- Mark Sanchez
6-15- Everybody Else
the only reason eli has to go to canton thus far is for peyton's induction ceremony.
Yeah Eli's claim to fame is a b.s. catch by Tyree and a crazy d-line in the Super Bowl. Eli is good but at this point Canton isn't calling haah
Originally Posted by hurdler388