Both suck lmao.
Both suck. Dont think either will be much more than a bench or platoon guy.
Justin Smoak: .270/.371/.434
Ike Davis: .171/.261/.253
With a 300 point lead in OPS, I think we can declare Smoak the obvious winner.
But Smoak actually is good or close to it. Has a 123 wRC+ on the year. Ill take that all day.
hey man i totally agree its almost as if we see something that the rest of these guys just aren't seeing... Right on!! to blueNorange's
Smoak is having a decent season. That does not prove he is a decent player yet.
Ike had a decen season last year.
If Smoak puts it together for 2-3 years in a row, I will consider him a decent player.
As of right now were are talking about two players who haven't proven to be everyday players.
But yes, Smoak lets better right now.....
Mostly because Ike looks like he doesn't belong in the big leagues.