fitzgerald is much better than boldin
now boldin will be nothing without fitzgerald
Printable View
fitzgerald is much better than boldin
now boldin will be nothing without fitzgerald
Larry Fitzgerald isn't 'much' better than Anquan Boldin. Both are pretty evenly rated by NFL scouts, saying one is better than the other doesn't mean much.Quote:
Originally Posted by papipapsmanny
Ok I'm from New England and I HATE the Pats but you can't take anything away from Randy Moss he mad some unbelievable catches last year I seen all of his games and he's just amazing he made Culpepper look good so u can't say it was simply just him having a good QB and I agree with Bolden = Fitzgerald its just Fitz is a fan favorite so gets more credit
But my list of overrated WRs are...
Steve Smith - he's fast but inconsistant
TJ Houz - didn't wanna spell it out lol but he got so many looks and TDs last year because of doubled up Chad
Kevin Curtis - I hate him with a passion my cousin is an Eagles fan and he's constantly raving about how amazing he is but no he had 1 game of his life
Bernard Berrian - Just another incosistant burner
Now that I think of it most fast WRs are overrated u were right haha good hands never get the props
How is Roddy White overrated? How many WRs have had numbers like his and made the same plays under 3 Different QBs? Leftwich Harrington and Redman? Be serious he's so underrated and overlooked because he's on a crap teamQuote:
Originally Posted by t mac and vick
I don't think Steve Smith is overrated at all. He's just had a lot of health problems over the last few years. This past year we was I believe dealing with a heel injury and tried to play through it, had 3-4 different QB's throwing him the ball and had nothing else at WR/TE to compliment him. Like Andre Johnson in Houston, they haven't put an offense around him to feature him as the truely great player he is.Quote:
Originally Posted by jaykobel
TJ Houshmandzadeh is a fine WR, but like you said, Chad Johnson gets a majority of the defenses attention, and the best CB's defending him, so his production is inflated. Good WR, but he's not better than Chad Johnson.
Nobody overrates Kevin Curtis, he's a medicore downfield speedster.
Bernard Berrian is a guy thats not really overrated by anyone, he can be inconsistant at times, but he's a nice player who gets in the endzone.
Moss would be top of my list.
What is your definition of Overated? Playing with so much effort that you play on a level above presumed talent level. Cause from your list the four of the players you list Don't understand the idea of coming off the field.Quote:
Originally Posted by ZHawk1123
Lee Evans however sucks, everyone knows he sucks know one respects his hands, routes, heart or knowledge of the game so even he is hard to call overrated.
Every First Round drafted WR out of USC.
But seriously where do you guys get these names?
I would think that over-rated WR means... A WR that Fans, Teams or the Media hype up to be better than they are. Am I wrong by that definition?
Most overated Number one from Last Year:
Darrell Jackson 49ers
Most overated Number two from last Year:
Donte Stalworth Patriots
Most overated in the last 10 years:
Joey Gallaway Bucs
Most Overated coming out of College in last 5 years years:
2008 - Anyone picked before Early Doucet
2007- Jurry still out But Jarrett or Ginn have my Money!
2006 - No one from this class to compare to.
2005 - Mike Williams / Troy Williamson (both top 10)
2004 jury still out (tie) Lee Evans 13th / Reggie Willaims 9th
2003 Charles Rodgers 2nd overall