PDA

View Full Version : Your Doug Melvin!!!



newtalker_27
07-10-2008, 04:37 PM
You can only sign One!

CC or Benny

Hardy or Hart

Weeks or Hardy

Hart/Gallardo or Fielder

Fielder vs CC or Sheets

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

I would sign CC or Benny

I would sign Hart over Hardy

I would sign Hardy over Weeks (easy here)

I would sign Hart & Gallardo over Fielder

I would sign Fielder over CC & Sheets ( I think all 3 may be gone next year)

Hart over Hardy

Brewersin08
07-10-2008, 04:52 PM
I would rather have CC over Sheets, he isn't an injury concern like Sheets and overall is a better pitcher. Hardy or Weeks? Are you kidding me? Not even a question, JJ. Hardy or Hart? I would take Hart, Escobar is in AAA. Prince, CC, or Sheets? I would take CC or Sheets over Prince. Power hitting firstbasemen are fairly common, and Matt Gamel could play 1st base for us. Aces, are not easy to find.

Segway2_89
07-10-2008, 04:54 PM
CC
Hart
Hardy
Hart/Gallardo
CC

Brew Crew
07-10-2008, 05:25 PM
[QUOTE=newtalker_27;5810791]You can only sign One!

CC or Benny - CC

Hardy or Hart - Hart

Weeks or Hardy - Hardy

Hart/Gallardo or Fielder - Hart and Gallardo

Fielder vs CC or Sheets - Fielder

wissportsfan
07-10-2008, 05:40 PM
You can only sign One!

CC or Benny

Hardy or Hart

Weeks or Hardy

Hart/Gallardo or Fielder

Fielder vs CC or Sheets

CC
Hart
Hardy
Hart/Gallardo
Fielder

hgtiger32
07-10-2008, 08:51 PM
we'll be able to keep hardy, hart, weeks, gallardo...and one of the pitchers...but since Prince is a Boras client ...he will get traded next season

i'd prefer CC...not injury prone

PackCrewBuckBad
07-10-2008, 08:59 PM
You can only sign One!

CC or Benny

Hardy or Hart

Weeks or Hardy

Hart/Gallardo or Fielder

Fielder vs CC or Sheets



CC
Hardy
Weeks
Gallardo/Hart
Fielder

There, only person we lose is Sheets.